Linux namespaces

Here we show a few recipes on how to deal with Linux namespaces from Emilua.

LWN.net has a good overview on Linux namespaces.

The user namespace

Unless you execute the process as root, Linux will deny the creation of all namespaces except for the user namespace. The user namespace is the only namespace that an unprivileged process can create. However it’s fine to pair the user namespace with any combination of the other ones.

When a user namespace is created, it starts out without a mapping of user IDs and group IDs to the parent user namespace. One can fill the mapping directly as shown in the example that follows:

local init_script = [[
    local uidmap = C.open('/proc/self/uid_map', C.O_WRONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', uidmap)
    C.write(C.open('/proc/self/setgroups', C.O_WRONLY), 'deny')
    local gidmap = C.open('/proc/self/gid_map', C.O_WRONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', gidmap)

    -- sync point
    C.read(arg, 1)
]]

local shost, sguest = unix.seqpacket_socket.pair()
sguest = sguest:release()

spawn_vm{
    subprocess = {
        newns_user = true,
        init = { script = init_script, arg = sguest }
    }
}
sguest:close()
local ignored_buf = byte_span.new(1)

local uidmap = ({system.getresuid()})[2]
uidmap = byte_span.append('0 ', tostring(uidmap), ' 1\n')
local uidmapfd = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
file.stream.new(uidmapfd):write_some(uidmap)

local gidmap = ({system.getresgid()})[2]
gidmap = byte_span.append('0 ', tostring(gidmap), ' 1\n')
local gidmapfd = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
file.stream.new(gidmapfd):write_some(gidmap)

-- sync point #1
shost:send(ignored_buf)

shost:close()

An AF_UNIX+SOCK_SEQPACKET socket is used to coordinate the parent and the child processes. This type of socket allows duplex communication between two parties with builtin framing for messages, disconnection detection (process reference counting if you will), and it also allows sending file descriptors back-and-forth.

We also close sguest from the host side as soon as we’re done with it. This will ensure any operation on shost will fail if the child process aborts for any reason (i.e. no deadlocks happen here).

Even if it’s a sandbox, and root inside the sandbox doesn’t mean root outside it, maybe you still want to drop all root privileges at the end of the subprocess.init.script:

C.cap_set_proc('=')

It won’t be particularly useful for most people, but that technique is still useful to — for instance — create alternative LXC/FlatPak front-ends to run a few programs (if the program can’t update its own binary files, new possibilities for sandboxing practice open up).

Alternatively, one can fill the mapping indirectly. Below we show how to do it using the suid-helper newuidmap:

local init_script = [[
    local pidfd = C.open('/proc/self', C.O_RDONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', pidfd)

    -- sync point
    C.read(arg, 1)
]]

local shost, sguest = unix.seqpacket_socket.pair()
sguest = sguest:release()

spawn_vm{
    subprocess = {
        newns_user = true,
        init = { script = init_script, arg = sguest }
    }
}
sguest:close()
local ignored_buf = byte_span.new(1)
local pidfd = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]

system.spawn{
    program = 'newuidmap',
    stdout = 'share',
    stderr = 'share',
    arguments = {
        'newuidmap',
        'fd:3', '0', '100000', '1001'
    },
    extra_fds = {
        [3] = pidfd
    }
}:wait()

system.spawn{
    program = 'newgidmap',
    stdout = 'share',
    stderr = 'share',
    arguments = {
        'newgidmap',
        'fd:3', '0', '100000', '1001'
    },
    extra_fds = {
        [3] = pidfd
    }
}:wait()

-- sync point #1
shost:send(ignored_buf)

shost:close()

You need to configure /etc/subuid to have newuidmap working.

The network namespace

Let’s start by isolating the network resources as that’s the easiest one:

spawn_vm{ subprocess = {
    newns_user = true,
    newns_net = true
} }

The process will be created within a new network namespace where no interfaces besides the loopback device exist. And even the loopback device will be down! If you want to configure the loopback device so the process can at least bind sockets to it you can use the program ip. However the program ip needs to run within the new namespace. To spawn the program ip within the namespace of the new actor you need to acquire the file descriptors to its namespaces. There are two ways to do that. You can either use race-prone PID primitives (easy), or you can use a handshake protocol to ensure that there are no races related to PID dances. Below we show the race-free method.

local init_script = [[
    local userns = C.open('/proc/self/ns/user', C.O_RDONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', userns)
    local netns = C.open('/proc/self/ns/net', C.O_RDONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', netns)

    -- sync point
    C.read(arg, 1)
]]

local shost, sguest = unix.seqpacket_socket.pair()
sguest = sguest:release()

spawn_vm{
    subprocess = {
        newns_user = true,
        newns_net = true,
        init = { script = init_script, arg = sguest }
    }
}
sguest:close()
local ignored_buf = byte_span.new(1)
local userns = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
local netns = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
system.spawn{
    program = 'ip',
    arguments = {'ip', 'link', 'set', 'dev', 'lo', 'up'},
    nsenter_user = userns,
    nsenter_net = netns
}:wait()
shost:close()

The PID namespace

When a new PID namespace is created, the process inside the new namespace ceases to see processes from the parent namespace. Your process still can see new processes created in the child’s namespace, so invisibility only happens in one direction. PID namespaces are hierarchically nested in parent-child relationships.

The first process in a PID namespace is PID1 within that namespace. PID1 has a few special responsibilities. After subprocess.init.script exits, the Emilua runtime will fork if it’s running as PID1. This new child will assume the role of starting your module (the Lua VM).

The controlling terminal

If you want to set up a pty in init.script, the PID1 will be the session leader. That way, the actor running in PID2 wouldn’t accidentally acquire a new ctty if it happens to open() a tty that isn’t currently controlling any session.

If the PID1 dies, all processes from that namespace (including further descendant PID namespaces) will be killed. This behavior allows you to fully dispose of a container when no longer needed by sending SIGKILL to PID1. No process will escape.

Communication topology may be arbitrarily defined as per the actor model, but the processes always assume a topology of a tree (supervision trees), and no PID namespace ever “re-parents”.

The Emilua runtime automatically sends SIGKILL to every process spawned using the Linux namespaces API when the actor that spawned them exits. If you want fine control over these processes, you can use a few extra methods that are available to the channel object that represents them.

The mount namespace

Let’s build up on our previous knowledge and build a sandbox with an empty "/" (that’s right!).

local init_script = [[
    ...

    -- unshare propagation events
    C.mount(nil, '/', nil, C.MS_PRIVATE)

    C.umask(0)
    C.mount(nil, '/mnt', 'tmpfs', 0)
    C.mkdir('/mnt/proc', mode(7, 5, 5))
    C.mount(nil, '/mnt/proc', 'proc', 0)
    C.mkdir('/mnt/tmp', mode(7, 7, 7))

    -- pivot root
    C.mkdir('/mnt/mnt', mode(7, 5, 5))
    C.chdir('/mnt')
    C.pivot_root('.', '/mnt/mnt')
    C.chroot('.')
    C.umount2('/mnt', C.MNT_DETACH)

    -- sync point
    C.read(arg, 1)
]]

spawn_vm{
    subprocess = {
        ...,
        newns_mount = true,

        -- let's go ahead and create a new
        -- PID namespace as well
        newns_pid = true
    }
}

We could certainly create a better initial "/". We could certainly do away with a few of the lines by cleverly reordering them. However the example is still nice to just illustrate a few of the syscalls exposed to the Lua script. There’s nothing particularly hard about mount namespaces. We just call a few syscalls, and no fd-dance between host and guest is really necessary.

One technique that we should mention is how module in spawn_vm(module) is interpreted when you use Linux namespaces. This argument no longer means an actual module when namespaces are involved. It’ll just be passed along to the new process. The following snippet shows you how to actually get the new actor in the container by finding a proper module to start.

local guest_code = [[
    local inbox = require 'inbox'
    local ip = require 'ip'

    local ch = inbox:receive().dest
    ch:send(ip.host_name())
]]

local init_script = [[
    ...

    local modulefd = C.open(
        '/app.lua',
        bit.bor(C.O_WRONLY, C.O_CREAT),
        mode(6, 0, 0))
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', modulefd)
]]

local my_channel = spawn_vm{ module = '/app.lua', ... }

...

local module = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
module = file.stream.new(module)
stream.write_all(module, guest_code)
shost:close()

my_channel:send{ dest = inbox }
print(inbox:receive())

Full example

local stream = require 'stream'
local system = require 'system'
local inbox = require 'inbox'
local file = require 'file'
local unix = require 'unix'

local guest_code = [[
    local inbox = require 'inbox'
    local ip = require 'ip'

    local ch = inbox:receive().dest
    ch:send(ip.host_name())
]]

local init_script = [[
    local uidmap = C.open('/proc/self/uid_map', C.O_WRONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', uidmap)
    C.write(C.open('/proc/self/setgroups', C.O_WRONLY), 'deny')
    local gidmap = C.open('/proc/self/gid_map', C.O_WRONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', gidmap)

    -- sync point #1 as tmpfs will fail on mkdir()
    -- with EOVERFLOW if no UID/GID mapping exists
    -- https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=183461
    C.read(arg, 1)

    local userns = C.open('/proc/self/ns/user', C.O_RDONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', userns)
    local netns = C.open('/proc/self/ns/net', C.O_RDONLY)
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', netns)

    -- unshare propagation events
    C.mount(nil, '/', nil, C.MS_PRIVATE)

    C.umask(0)
    C.mount(nil, '/mnt', 'tmpfs', 0)
    C.mkdir('/mnt/proc', mode(7, 5, 5))
    C.mount(nil, '/mnt/proc', 'proc', 0)
    C.mkdir('/mnt/tmp', mode(7, 7, 7))

    -- pivot root
    C.mkdir('/mnt/mnt', mode(7, 5, 5))
    C.chdir('/mnt')
    C.pivot_root('.', '/mnt/mnt')
    C.chroot('.')
    C.umount2('/mnt', C.MNT_DETACH)

    local modulefd = C.open(
        '/app.lua',
        bit.bor(C.O_WRONLY, C.O_CREAT),
        mode(6, 0, 0))
    send_with_fd(arg, '.', modulefd)

    -- sync point #2 as we must await for
    --
    -- * loopback net device
    -- * `/app.lua`
    --
    -- before we run the guest
    C.read(arg, 1)

    C.sethostname('mycoolhostname')
    C.setdomainname('mycooldomainname')

    -- drop all root privileges
    C.cap_set_proc('=')
]]

local shost, sguest = unix.seqpacket_socket.pair()
sguest = sguest:release()

local my_channel = spawn_vm{
    module = '/app.lua',
    subprocess = {
        newns_user = true,
        newns_net = true,
        newns_mount = true,
        newns_pid = true,
        newns_uts = true,
        newns_ipc = true,
        init = { script = init_script, arg = sguest }
    }
}
sguest:close()

local ignored_buf = byte_span.new(1)

local uidmap = ({system.getresuid()})[2]
uidmap = byte_span.append('0 ', tostring(uidmap), ' 1\n')
local uidmapfd = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
file.stream.new(uidmapfd):write_some(uidmap)

local gidmap = ({system.getresgid()})[2]
gidmap = byte_span.append('0 ', tostring(gidmap), ' 1\n')
local gidmapfd = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
file.stream.new(gidmapfd):write_some(gidmap)

-- sync point #1
shost:send(ignored_buf)

local userns = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
local netns = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
system.spawn{
    program = 'ip',
    arguments = {'ip', 'link', 'set', 'dev', 'lo', 'up'},
    nsenter_user = userns,
    nsenter_net = netns
}:wait()

local module = ({shost:receive_with_fds(ignored_buf, 1)})[2][1]
module = file.stream.new(module)
stream.write_all(module, guest_code)

-- sync point #2
shost:close()

my_channel:send{ dest = inbox }
print(inbox:receive())